Skip to main content

Microsoft's Vista Is Not For The Faint of Heart

I needed a new computer. I decided to buy an HP Pavilion Notebook on sale at a local retailer. The HP notebook only came with Microsoft Windows Vista software. There were no new computers of any brand available with Windows XP any longer. (I know it's possible to buy XP and change the OS, but who wants to go to that much trouble?)

To put it bluntly, Vista is a nightmare. So far I've spent roughly 20 hours on the phone with Tech support from both HP and Microsoft. In general, the support staff have tried to be helpful but don't know how to diagnose, much less fix, the multitude of Vista issues. Among the many nasty surprises I've had with Vista are the following:
  • Initially ITunes was un-usuable until I discovered (by myself without help from any Microsoft or HP tech support who should have known this) that a Microsoft Vista update was required to have been installed before installation of ITunes 7.3.
  • Having fixed ITunes myself, I then discovered that my IPOD itself was also un-usable, because it somehow causes Vista to fail to restart.
  • My HP printers are obsolete as HP decided not to migrate them to Vista
  • None of my older Thumb drives work with Vista
  • The HP docking station for the Notebook running Vista has driver problems with Vista
  • The Microsoft approach to Vista compatibility seems to me to aimed solely at upgrading existing PCs running XP to Vista. There is almost no help from Microsoft at identifying compatibility issues or installation problems with existing software (i.e. ITunes) on the Vista OS in a new computer.

Why am I enduring this punishment? I have yet to discover anything even remotely better about Vista in everyday operation. Microsoft lists twelve things I should be grateful for, but I don't get it with any of them:

  1. Aero Aesthetics - I'm not that impressed with the "translucent" aesthetic UI. Initially I find that it seems to cause active windows to be very touchy and annoyingly easy to close by accident.
  2. Common Controls - So what, they finally made the UI controls relatively consistent across the OS and Office suites.
  3. Notifications - So far, I'm feeling notified to death.
  4. Search Boxes - So what? Now I've got a whole bunch of search boxes that still take me to places that have information that is of little of no value.
  5. Task Dialogs - This computer is for my wife who would be the first to admit that she is not now, nor does she ever want to be, tech savy. So "task dialogs" are a new source of dread and frustration. "Oh my god, there are six choices for this task, what do I do now?"
  6. Aero Wizards - Wizards are not new? OK maybe they got the look and feel more consistent of something. Big deal.
  7. Common Dialogs - We're talking files and folders here gang. Haven't really seen much improvement, and the new "look" caused me to have to rethink how to use it.
  8. Control Panels - I immediately put it back in Control Panel classic view because I just don't have time for all the control panel improvements such as "a more scalable interface that can better handle large sets of settings." Just what I wanted a larger set of settings?
  9. Style and Tone - I will give them an "A" for effort here. So far I haven't run across any of those old nasty-grams from Microsoft like "you failed to properly...do this or that." They've toned it down with a new friendly writing style and tone of voice.
  10. Icons - They think the Icons are better than they use to be at describing what they do. Personally, I can't tell the difference. They are prettier.
  11. System Font (Segoe UI) - They also thing their new font is the cats pajamas. It just looks like Arial narrow to me.
  12. User Account Control - They don't even know what this is, there is no explaination for what they mean.

Have fun if you try Vista, I sure did.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

John Malone on America and Obama

You just have to love Dr. John Malone. The guy's a certified genius but also a "what you see is what you get" straight-shooting kind of guy. His Ph.D. is from Johns Hopkins, BA is science from Yale, worth $2.3 billion (according to Forbes, but probably way low because they just couldn't find all of it). He ran TCI (America's largest Cable company) and sold it to ATT for $54 billion. He's the kind of person that you could just sit and listen to for hours. He's so logical, well informed and well spoken. In a recent interview with the Wall Street Journal here's a few nuggets from what he had to say... (I agree with him about Obama) WSJ: What are the biggest risks for Liberty right now? Mr. Malone: I think the biggest concern I have for the next year or two would be on the retail side, because of the consumer sentiment and the macro conditions. The concerns really tend to be much more macro: Is America going to make it, rather than are we going to make it?...

Barry Schwartz - The Paradox of Choice

MediaPost Publications - Americans Get More Channels, Watch Fewer Of Them, Especially Broadcast - 03/13/2006 Ironically, Barry Schwartz spoke at PC Forum last night about the Paradox of Choice, and what did I wake up to this morning. Another possible example of too much choice in the channels people have to choose from on television. I wonder whether the "a la carte" crowd has thought about this problem. I'll have to ask Prof. Schwartz about that today.

The Evolving Internet: A look ahead to 2025 by Cisco and the Monitor Group's Global Business Network

My employer (Cisco) published its most recent forward looking study of the Internet today. It's called " The Evolving Internet: A look ahead to 2025 by Cisco and the Monitor Group's Global Business Network " and although I haven't studied it in detail yet, I scanned it this morning and I liked what I saw. Those who know me will not be surprised that I particularly liked the three dimensional evaluation criteria that they used to frame their analysis. Lately nearly everything I do ends up finding its way into some sort of analytical cube like this. I've been wondering whether there is something wrong with me that I can't seem to frame things simply in two dimensions. Glad to have company.